Tuesday, 13 June 2017
COMPONENT 1B - Revision Lesson 4 - Example paragraphs
I'm only giving you 2 example paragraphs for legal/courtroom transcripts. You'll have to research others alone.
Here is the imagined question:
'Using the stimulus as a starting point, discuss how legal power can be exerted through language use.'
So - imagine that the first 2 paragraphs have been answered in relation to the stimulus, here is what the next 2 COULD look like...
P3 - Within an extract from the murder case involving ex-athlete Oscar Pistorius, we studied an exchange between a defence barrister and a key witness. Within this exchange, power is exerted by the barrister when he attempts to undermine the witness and make them look less reliable. This is due to the fact that the barrister is probably attempting to defame the witness and prove reasonable doubt over the guilt of Pistorius. At first, 'D' demonstrates upwards convergence by saying to the witness 'let me explain to you what it means...when you testified'. here, the use of the imperative with the fronted verb 'let', along with the rather patronising verb 'explain' characterises the witness as unintelligent and lacking in legal know-how, which might cast doubt over her reliability in this context. Later, further unreliability is cast upon her when the barrister claims that she made 'no mention of the woman's screaming (1) no mention'. The use of repetition to draw attention to the negated common noun 'no mention', particularly when coupled with a planned unvoiced pause for effect, would accentuate the gap in the witness's version of events, despite her otherwise being trustworthy. This would be classed by Goffman as a 'face threatening act'. However, a different aspect of face presents itself later in the extract when the barrister protects the negative face of the witness, presumably to encourage compliance from her. We can see this firstly when the barrister repeatedly uses the imperative phrase 'hear me out', which undermines his opwn ego and makes it appear as if he is asking the witness' permission to continue, despite being in a position of power relative to her. He later follows an extremely long sentence with 'and I apologise for that'. here, the use of the first person singular pronoun and dynamic present tense verb 'I apologise' show that the barrister is deliberately attempting to pander to the negative face needs of the witness so that she will feel more inclined to talk and comply with his wishes.
P4 - In a similar courtroom extract, we examined data where a man named 'Mr Neil' was being interrogated by a barrister having got into a dispute with a neighbour after an incident with a car. Within the extract, we see the barrister attempting to distance himself from the witness in order to elevate his position of power. An example of this, near the start of the extract, is when the barrister uses low frequency lexis such as the noun 'incident', adverb 'previously' and noun 'grudge' to make him sound more educated than the defendant. The barrister subtly mocks the reliability of the defendant by repeating elements of his own words such as 'you can't remember whether [the police] came to see you?'. Here, the contraction 'can't' and dynamic verb 'remember', which would have been said in an incredulous tone, paints a picture of the defendant as unreliable and fanciful, probably causing the jury to discount his evidence. In a similar way to how the barrister in text A appealed to the negative face needs of his witness to encourage compliance, this barrister in this text uses a similar technique by using downwards convergence to speak to him more on his level. On the surface, he appears to sympathise with the defendant, saying, '...the reason there is ill feeling...is that you believe Mr Peterson shopped you to the police.' here, the use of the abstract noun reason, connoting understanding, and the colloquial past participle verb 'shopped' imply that the barrister is attempting to encourage the defendant to cooperate with him as he has started to see things from his point of view. This would make it far more likely that the defendant will say something which will incriminate him.
Here is the imagined question:
'Using the stimulus as a starting point, discuss how legal power can be exerted through language use.'
So - imagine that the first 2 paragraphs have been answered in relation to the stimulus, here is what the next 2 COULD look like...
P3 - Within an extract from the murder case involving ex-athlete Oscar Pistorius, we studied an exchange between a defence barrister and a key witness. Within this exchange, power is exerted by the barrister when he attempts to undermine the witness and make them look less reliable. This is due to the fact that the barrister is probably attempting to defame the witness and prove reasonable doubt over the guilt of Pistorius. At first, 'D' demonstrates upwards convergence by saying to the witness 'let me explain to you what it means...when you testified'. here, the use of the imperative with the fronted verb 'let', along with the rather patronising verb 'explain' characterises the witness as unintelligent and lacking in legal know-how, which might cast doubt over her reliability in this context. Later, further unreliability is cast upon her when the barrister claims that she made 'no mention of the woman's screaming (1) no mention'. The use of repetition to draw attention to the negated common noun 'no mention', particularly when coupled with a planned unvoiced pause for effect, would accentuate the gap in the witness's version of events, despite her otherwise being trustworthy. This would be classed by Goffman as a 'face threatening act'. However, a different aspect of face presents itself later in the extract when the barrister protects the negative face of the witness, presumably to encourage compliance from her. We can see this firstly when the barrister repeatedly uses the imperative phrase 'hear me out', which undermines his opwn ego and makes it appear as if he is asking the witness' permission to continue, despite being in a position of power relative to her. He later follows an extremely long sentence with 'and I apologise for that'. here, the use of the first person singular pronoun and dynamic present tense verb 'I apologise' show that the barrister is deliberately attempting to pander to the negative face needs of the witness so that she will feel more inclined to talk and comply with his wishes.
P4 - In a similar courtroom extract, we examined data where a man named 'Mr Neil' was being interrogated by a barrister having got into a dispute with a neighbour after an incident with a car. Within the extract, we see the barrister attempting to distance himself from the witness in order to elevate his position of power. An example of this, near the start of the extract, is when the barrister uses low frequency lexis such as the noun 'incident', adverb 'previously' and noun 'grudge' to make him sound more educated than the defendant. The barrister subtly mocks the reliability of the defendant by repeating elements of his own words such as 'you can't remember whether [the police] came to see you?'. Here, the contraction 'can't' and dynamic verb 'remember', which would have been said in an incredulous tone, paints a picture of the defendant as unreliable and fanciful, probably causing the jury to discount his evidence. In a similar way to how the barrister in text A appealed to the negative face needs of his witness to encourage compliance, this barrister in this text uses a similar technique by using downwards convergence to speak to him more on his level. On the surface, he appears to sympathise with the defendant, saying, '...the reason there is ill feeling...is that you believe Mr Peterson shopped you to the police.' here, the use of the abstract noun reason, connoting understanding, and the colloquial past participle verb 'shopped' imply that the barrister is attempting to encourage the defendant to cooperate with him as he has started to see things from his point of view. This would make it far more likely that the defendant will say something which will incriminate him.
THEORIES - OVERVIEW
You should, by now, be well on your way to learning what various theorists have to say.
However, if you want a VERY BASIC tick-list (you have been taught far more than these), then find some quotes or ideas from the following. Even if you can't remember exact quotes, at least ensure you are able to summarise their ideas.
Section A
Fairclough - features of dominance, instrumental and influential power etc
Grice's maxims
Goffman/Brown and Levinson - Face
Convergence/Divergence
Code-Switching
Overt/Covert Prestige
Accommodation Theory - Howard Giles
Section B
Power
Political
All of the above plus Noam Chomsky and George Orwell (essay by Orwell was sent out by email at the time)
Advetising
All from section A could be relevant
Legalese/Legal
Noam Chomsky and George Orwell could be relevant as could all general ones
In Conversation
All of the above
Situation
Political Correctness
Stephen Pinker - Euphemism Treadmill
Anything tech based
Look at the David Crystal Powerpoint I sent to you
General
All of the above could be relevant
Standard/ Non-Standard
Handouts available on blog:
David Crystal
Peter Trudgill
John Honey
Jean Aitchison (Damp Spoon, Crumbling Castle, Infectious Disease)
Donald MacKinnon - Public attitudes to language variation
However, if you want a VERY BASIC tick-list (you have been taught far more than these), then find some quotes or ideas from the following. Even if you can't remember exact quotes, at least ensure you are able to summarise their ideas.
Section A
Fairclough - features of dominance, instrumental and influential power etc
Grice's maxims
Goffman/Brown and Levinson - Face
Convergence/Divergence
Code-Switching
Overt/Covert Prestige
Accommodation Theory - Howard Giles
Section B
Power
Political
All of the above plus Noam Chomsky and George Orwell (essay by Orwell was sent out by email at the time)
Advetising
All from section A could be relevant
Legalese/Legal
Noam Chomsky and George Orwell could be relevant as could all general ones
In Conversation
All of the above
Situation
Political Correctness
Stephen Pinker - Euphemism Treadmill
Anything tech based
Look at the David Crystal Powerpoint I sent to you
General
All of the above could be relevant
Standard/ Non-Standard
Handouts available on blog:
David Crystal
Peter Trudgill
John Honey
Jean Aitchison (Damp Spoon, Crumbling Castle, Infectious Disease)
Donald MacKinnon - Public attitudes to language variation
GENERAL ADVICE - COMPONENT 1
So everyone,
This first exam is tomorrow, so this may be the final time you look at the blog (thought I am adding some things as we speak up until about 5pm).
Here is the most GENERAL advice I can give you.
1. Stick to your timings. If you mess up your timings, then you will struggle. It may be that you finish section B with a little time to spare and can go back to add one or two PGs onto the speech section, but don't count on this. Aim to get your planning and essay of Section A done in about 65 minutes, and then spend 55 on the 'Language Issues' question.
2. Section A - Introduce each text independently and then aim to write 6-8 separate points on each texts, making brief comparisons to the other text along the way.
3. Make sure you make a variety of points, considering how the context, audience and position of speakers is affecting what is being said. Make sure you cover ALL the key points in each text - don't just focus on the top half of the text.
4. Ensure you are COMPARING the texts in your essay (look at the example I'm putting on here if you are stuck).
5. Use LOTS of terms where relevant, especially specific Speech Terms. Don't classify every words, but do make a big deal out of IMPORTANT words.
6. Not all PGs need to be huge. If your first 2, for example, are very detailed, but your third points is not quite so significant, it can be much shorter. Again, see example.
7. In total, your essay should be between 12-15 paragraphs long.
8. Section B - There will be a choice of three questions but YOU MUST ONLY ANSWER ONE. Choose the question very wisely based on what subject area (situation/power/standardnonstandard) you know best. DO NOT ATTEMPT ANY QUESTION TO DO WITH CHILD LANGUAGE LEARNING/ACQUISITION - YOU HAVE NOT LEARNED THIS.
9. You need to answer on the extract for about 2-3 paragraphs, and then write at least 4-5 paragraphs of the essay on your wider reading. You must read the question extremely carefully so that you know which sources are relevant to use. In total, this essay should be around 6-9 paragraphs long, though some might be very detailed..
10. You must include some relevant theories and quotes from theorists to hit the top marks.
11. Your stimulus text will either be an extract of some sort, in which case you need to pick out quotes and explain how/why language is working the way it is in relation to your question; or it may be a piece of writing where someone is expressing an opinion. If someone is expressing an opinion, you should isolate their ideas, analyse the quotes using terms, and try to apply theories to what they have said (for example, say whether or not they are descriptivist/prescriptivist and talk about which theorists would agree/disagree with them.)
12. DO NOT PANIC. Whatever questions you get, pick your strongest option, then spend some time recalling some relevant points from your wider reading. Then just treat it like any other essay where you write to the best of your ability. Panicking NEVER helps.
Good luck and keep checking the blog.
This first exam is tomorrow, so this may be the final time you look at the blog (thought I am adding some things as we speak up until about 5pm).
Here is the most GENERAL advice I can give you.
1. Stick to your timings. If you mess up your timings, then you will struggle. It may be that you finish section B with a little time to spare and can go back to add one or two PGs onto the speech section, but don't count on this. Aim to get your planning and essay of Section A done in about 65 minutes, and then spend 55 on the 'Language Issues' question.
2. Section A - Introduce each text independently and then aim to write 6-8 separate points on each texts, making brief comparisons to the other text along the way.
3. Make sure you make a variety of points, considering how the context, audience and position of speakers is affecting what is being said. Make sure you cover ALL the key points in each text - don't just focus on the top half of the text.
4. Ensure you are COMPARING the texts in your essay (look at the example I'm putting on here if you are stuck).
5. Use LOTS of terms where relevant, especially specific Speech Terms. Don't classify every words, but do make a big deal out of IMPORTANT words.
6. Not all PGs need to be huge. If your first 2, for example, are very detailed, but your third points is not quite so significant, it can be much shorter. Again, see example.
7. In total, your essay should be between 12-15 paragraphs long.
8. Section B - There will be a choice of three questions but YOU MUST ONLY ANSWER ONE. Choose the question very wisely based on what subject area (situation/power/standardnonstandard) you know best. DO NOT ATTEMPT ANY QUESTION TO DO WITH CHILD LANGUAGE LEARNING/ACQUISITION - YOU HAVE NOT LEARNED THIS.
9. You need to answer on the extract for about 2-3 paragraphs, and then write at least 4-5 paragraphs of the essay on your wider reading. You must read the question extremely carefully so that you know which sources are relevant to use. In total, this essay should be around 6-9 paragraphs long, though some might be very detailed..
10. You must include some relevant theories and quotes from theorists to hit the top marks.
11. Your stimulus text will either be an extract of some sort, in which case you need to pick out quotes and explain how/why language is working the way it is in relation to your question; or it may be a piece of writing where someone is expressing an opinion. If someone is expressing an opinion, you should isolate their ideas, analyse the quotes using terms, and try to apply theories to what they have said (for example, say whether or not they are descriptivist/prescriptivist and talk about which theorists would agree/disagree with them.)
12. DO NOT PANIC. Whatever questions you get, pick your strongest option, then spend some time recalling some relevant points from your wider reading. Then just treat it like any other essay where you write to the best of your ability. Panicking NEVER helps.
Good luck and keep checking the blog.
COMPONENT 1B - Revision Lesson 4
So, in this lesson, we looked at legal power in the context of courtroom transcripts, and how these can show power. These texts could also be used for situation.
The first text is a transcript of a discussion between a barrister and a defendant over a local dispute. The second is a transcript of a cross-examination of a witness in the Oscar Pistorius murder trial.
Other examples of courtroom transcripts for your own research can be found at this link: http://dailycaller.com/2016/06/23/suck-my-d-read-the-most-insane-court-transcript-in-us-history/
Monday, 12 June 2017
COMPONENT 1B - Revision lesson 3 - Example paragraphs
Hi all,
Before reading these paragraphs, please take note. PRAGMATICS is hugely important when it comes to power in advertising. As a lot of your theories relate to power in CONVERSATION, they will mainly not be relevant in printed adverts.
You may talk about INSTRUMENTAL POWER (Fairclough) if the text is from an authority figure. You could also mention INFLUENTIAL POWER (Also Fairclough). You could also mention Grice. Also, if the advert mimics speech, it may well be that Fairclough's features of dominance of 'Face' could be mentioned (For example, if a rhetorical question was used to commit a FTA, or if the advert seemed to be preserving the reader's negative face).
However, largely you will need to focus on PRAGMATICS. By this I mean, talking about why CERTAIN WORDS are important in CERTAIN SITUATIONS (Contexts/Target audiences).
Because of this, I have chosen texts where pragmatics is very important. You do not need to mention the word 'pragmatically' or 'pragmatics'. Just say something like, 'This noun takes on extra significance when we consider the target audience of elderly women because...'
So, here are some example paragraphs:
You will already have done 2 on the stimulus text. Here are another 3!
P3 - An additional example of a powerful advert which I have studied is an extremely emotive appeal by 'Pancreatic Cancer Action'. Within this advert, power is exerted through the use of direct speech in the form of the controversial declarative, 'I wish I had breast cancer.' By juxtaposing the emotive verb 'wish' with the common noun 'cancer', the author creates a sense of shock and intrigue in the reader, pressuring them to read on to find an explanation for this shocking admission. These words would be received particularly alarmingly by a modern audience who are frequently bombarded with appeals to aid cancer charities. Perhaps this is an attempt to stand out from other similar appeals. Power is also exerted through synthetic personalisation by ensuring the quote appears to be from a real person 'Kerry, 24'. The inclusion of her age would shock the audience and make them feel vulnerable, increasing the likelihood they might want to help. By using the adverb 'today, the author is able to exaggerate the seriousness of the problem faced by many, putting it into context. Additionally, the use of superlative phrases 'biggest cancer killer' and 'lowest survival rate', the disease is inflated hyperbolically to make it seem more of a threat, increasing peoples' interest in the topic. The use of the abstract noun 'action' in the title of the charity contrasts with the more passive 'research' in the title of the UKs biggest cancer charity, perhaps making the reader more likely to donate due to the fact they may think their money will be spent fighting the disease rather than simply researching.
P4 - In a hugely contrasting advert for Maybelline's 'Colossal Spider Effect' mascara, the advert exerts power by targeting a specific demographic of insecure young women in order to use language for maximum effect. Utilising an imperative tone throughout, the advert leads with the command 'open your eyes', the idiom simultaneously implying that the product will increase the size of your eyes, whilst also seemingly implying that the reader is naïve if they do not yet use the product, which may encourage them to buy it. Later in the advert, the effect of the product is billed as 'Boldly Sculpted Lashes'. Here, the adverb 'boldly' implies that a person can improve their shy personality by using the product, and the adjective 'sculpted' seems to suggest that it is preferable to appear different to how you do naturally, implying that readers should always see themselves as a work in progress. The title of the product 'colossal spider' is seemingly designed to polarise the target demographic as the adjective 'colossal' and noun 'spider' sound eye-catching and over-the-top simultaneously. Then result of this may be that more shy readers see the product as a way to improve themselves, and more bold readers may feel pressured into using it to be on trend.
P5 - In an advert run by Martin Guitars, the text exerts power over the reader by insinuating that by buying a Martin guitar, you are buying into a legacy, exemplified by the declarative that Heather's guitar teacher 'introduced her...to a guitar that would change her life.' Clearly an example of Norman Fairclough's 'Influential Power', the past participle verb 'introduced' seemingly personifies the guitar. This idea is continued through the statement that on their last lesson together, the teacher 'passed down' a guitar to her. The phrasal verb implies a sense of tradition an cross-generational appreciation, raising the prestige of the guitars in question. Arguably, here - as an older guitar company - Martin Guitars attempt to appear as if they have instrumental power by seemingly claiming that they are a cut above their competitors. The advert even seems to put off some potential buyers, claiming 'A Martin guitar is nothing unless you know how to play one.' The use of direct address shown through the second person pronoun 'you', coupled with the sensationalist indefinite pronoun 'nothing' seems to put the onus on the customer to prove their worth and commitment, and prove that they are worthy of owning a Martin guitar, a very bold application of power.
Have a go at writing a paragraph for the 4th text by yourself.
Before reading these paragraphs, please take note. PRAGMATICS is hugely important when it comes to power in advertising. As a lot of your theories relate to power in CONVERSATION, they will mainly not be relevant in printed adverts.
You may talk about INSTRUMENTAL POWER (Fairclough) if the text is from an authority figure. You could also mention INFLUENTIAL POWER (Also Fairclough). You could also mention Grice. Also, if the advert mimics speech, it may well be that Fairclough's features of dominance of 'Face' could be mentioned (For example, if a rhetorical question was used to commit a FTA, or if the advert seemed to be preserving the reader's negative face).
However, largely you will need to focus on PRAGMATICS. By this I mean, talking about why CERTAIN WORDS are important in CERTAIN SITUATIONS (Contexts/Target audiences).
Because of this, I have chosen texts where pragmatics is very important. You do not need to mention the word 'pragmatically' or 'pragmatics'. Just say something like, 'This noun takes on extra significance when we consider the target audience of elderly women because...'
So, here are some example paragraphs:
You will already have done 2 on the stimulus text. Here are another 3!
P3 - An additional example of a powerful advert which I have studied is an extremely emotive appeal by 'Pancreatic Cancer Action'. Within this advert, power is exerted through the use of direct speech in the form of the controversial declarative, 'I wish I had breast cancer.' By juxtaposing the emotive verb 'wish' with the common noun 'cancer', the author creates a sense of shock and intrigue in the reader, pressuring them to read on to find an explanation for this shocking admission. These words would be received particularly alarmingly by a modern audience who are frequently bombarded with appeals to aid cancer charities. Perhaps this is an attempt to stand out from other similar appeals. Power is also exerted through synthetic personalisation by ensuring the quote appears to be from a real person 'Kerry, 24'. The inclusion of her age would shock the audience and make them feel vulnerable, increasing the likelihood they might want to help. By using the adverb 'today, the author is able to exaggerate the seriousness of the problem faced by many, putting it into context. Additionally, the use of superlative phrases 'biggest cancer killer' and 'lowest survival rate', the disease is inflated hyperbolically to make it seem more of a threat, increasing peoples' interest in the topic. The use of the abstract noun 'action' in the title of the charity contrasts with the more passive 'research' in the title of the UKs biggest cancer charity, perhaps making the reader more likely to donate due to the fact they may think their money will be spent fighting the disease rather than simply researching.
P4 - In a hugely contrasting advert for Maybelline's 'Colossal Spider Effect' mascara, the advert exerts power by targeting a specific demographic of insecure young women in order to use language for maximum effect. Utilising an imperative tone throughout, the advert leads with the command 'open your eyes', the idiom simultaneously implying that the product will increase the size of your eyes, whilst also seemingly implying that the reader is naïve if they do not yet use the product, which may encourage them to buy it. Later in the advert, the effect of the product is billed as 'Boldly Sculpted Lashes'. Here, the adverb 'boldly' implies that a person can improve their shy personality by using the product, and the adjective 'sculpted' seems to suggest that it is preferable to appear different to how you do naturally, implying that readers should always see themselves as a work in progress. The title of the product 'colossal spider' is seemingly designed to polarise the target demographic as the adjective 'colossal' and noun 'spider' sound eye-catching and over-the-top simultaneously. Then result of this may be that more shy readers see the product as a way to improve themselves, and more bold readers may feel pressured into using it to be on trend.
P5 - In an advert run by Martin Guitars, the text exerts power over the reader by insinuating that by buying a Martin guitar, you are buying into a legacy, exemplified by the declarative that Heather's guitar teacher 'introduced her...to a guitar that would change her life.' Clearly an example of Norman Fairclough's 'Influential Power', the past participle verb 'introduced' seemingly personifies the guitar. This idea is continued through the statement that on their last lesson together, the teacher 'passed down' a guitar to her. The phrasal verb implies a sense of tradition an cross-generational appreciation, raising the prestige of the guitars in question. Arguably, here - as an older guitar company - Martin Guitars attempt to appear as if they have instrumental power by seemingly claiming that they are a cut above their competitors. The advert even seems to put off some potential buyers, claiming 'A Martin guitar is nothing unless you know how to play one.' The use of direct address shown through the second person pronoun 'you', coupled with the sensationalist indefinite pronoun 'nothing' seems to put the onus on the customer to prove their worth and commitment, and prove that they are worthy of owning a Martin guitar, a very bold application of power.
Have a go at writing a paragraph for the 4th text by yourself.
COMPONENT 1B - Revision lesson 3
Here are some example paragraphs based on the following question:
Using the stimulus as a starting point, discuss how language can be used in advertising to exert power.
Here are the texts we will be looking at:
Using the stimulus as a starting point, discuss how language can be used in advertising to exert power.
Here are the texts we will be looking at:
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)








